Pennsylvania Attorney General Sunday Joins Comment Letter Urging Feds to Reject Proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Merger that will Increase Costs, Cut Services and Workforces

(File Photo: Source for Photo: Norfolk Southern locomotives are moved in Norfolk Southern’s Conway Terminal in Conway, Pa., Saturday, June 17, 2023. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

Noah Haswell, Beaver County Radio News

(Harrisburg, PA) According to a release yesterday from Pennsylvania Attorney General Dave Sunday’s office, Sunday and the Office of Attorney General’s Antitrust Section are sending comments to the federal Surface Transportation Board (STB) outlining potential negative impacts for Pennsylvania regarding the proposed merger of Union Pacific Railroad Company and Norfolk Southern Railway Company.

This proposed $85 billion merger would give Union Pacific a 40 percent share of all rail freight traffic in the United States, which is more than 50,000 miles in 43 states, including Pennsylvania. 

Attorney General Sunday and the OAG’s Antitrust Section cited past examples of Class I railroad mergers which resulted in higher shipping costs, due to fewer competitors, and this decreased efficiency and workforces.

Pennsylvania has the most operating railroads of any state in the United States with 65, and the third most in the country in rail miles with 5,600.

States do not have the authority to challenge railroad mergers in court and under federal law, the STB has the sole authority to approve such a merger. 

The bipartisan coalition, which includes 21 states, is asking the STB to reject the merger. 

According to Sunday: “Our Commonwealth relies every day on rail lines to commute to work, visit friends and family, and transport goods, so when a major rail provider merges with another, that means one less major competitor in the market. “We will be urging the Feds to look and learn from past examples and the ensuing fallout. Our Antitrust Section has reviewed this potential merger, and identified a bevy of potential harm for Pennsylvania families and businesses.”

The merger will adversely affect railway service, short-line rail, and labor markets in creating the largest private rail system in American history.

The attorneys general of Arizona, Colorado, District of Columbia, Florida, Illinois, Kansas, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Nevada, Oregon, South Dakota, Virginia, Washington, and Wisconsin are joining Pennsylvania in the bipartisan coalition.

The attorneys general assert that the merger fails the merger standard of the STB which requires the merging parties to show “substantial and demonstrable public benefits to the transaction that cannot otherwise be achieved.”

Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern have not offered proposals that are sufficient that would remedy the harms to competition and the effects that are adverse on trading partners and the public which are likely to result from the merger, on the contrary.

Furthermore, instead of giving proper assurances to those that are most at risk of harm due to the merger, the CEO of Union Pacific has made threats to raise the prices for shipping customers who do not support the merger instead.