(File Photo of the Heritage Valley Health System Logo)
Noah Haswell, Beaver County Radio News
(Sewickley, PA) An emergency room nurse at Heritage Valley Sewickley Hospital who was using narcotics he had stolen from the hospital caused the death of at least two patients, according to a six-count whistleblower lawsuit filed against the health system.
Heritage Valley Health System, CEO Norm Mitry, chief nursing officer Linda Homyk and other hospital physicians and managers were named in the lawsuit. It was filed in February by the Pittsburgh office of Saul Ewing LLP and was unsealed on June 15th by U.S. District Court Judge Cathy Bissoon.
Registered nurses Jennifer Duckett and Samantha Gallo allege in the lawsuit that co-worker Nolan D. Chismire of Baden was sometimes so intoxicated when caring for patients that he had trouble walking. They allege that he caused the 2024 death of a 70-year-old woman who came to the emergency room with a non-life-threatening condition and died after he delayed her care, then made an error in administering a medication, according to the lawsuit.
In a second instance later that year, Chismire denied care to a 47-year-old man who was experiencing symptoms of alcohol withdrawal.
The man left the emergency room without medical attention and was later found in the hospital parking lot with a bleeding head wound. He was transferred to Allegheny General Hospital, which was where he died.
The lawsuit confirms that at least six nurses from HVHS, including Chismire’s wife, Tina, who is also a registered nurse at Heritage Valley Sewickley, alerted hospital officials about Chismire’s alleged drug problem between 2021 and 2025. The alleged drug problems began shortly after he received his nursing license in 2009 and it continued at HVHS, which was where he was often absent from duty for hours when he was suspected of using drugs.
According to the lawsuit, Chismire had worked at a nursing home and hospital, where he stole morphine, fentanyl and other narcotics. He was hired at HVHS in 2017 after he completed a 14-month drug rehabilitation program and while on probation by the state board of nursing.















