Andrew A. “Andy” Toncic, Sr., 96, a lifelong resident of Midland, passed away peacefully surrounded by family on November 9th, 2025. He was born on July 14, 1929, a son of the late Andrija and Fanika Puc Toncic. In addition to his parents, he was preceded in death by his first wife of 41 years, Lydia Orlando Toncic; his second wife of 21 years, Delores Kane Toncic; his daughter, Regina M. Toncic; his sister, Luby (Thomas) Wuchina; and his brother, Ivan (Beverly) Toncic. He is survived by his loving children: Andrew Jr., John (Lisa) Kane, Vince (Dee) Kane, and Connie (Tom) Kampian. He was a proud and devoted “Pata” to his grandchildren, Tabatha Thomas, John (Kaitlin) Kearney, and Michael Kearney, and to his great-grandchildren, Emersen Patten and Jordyn, Jax, and Jace Kearney. He also leaves behind many beloved nieces, nephews, and extended family members who will miss him dearly.
Andrew leaves behind a legacy of kindness, integrity, and devotion to family and community. He was a graduate of Midland High School, who served as captain of both the football and basketball teams. He was a talented athlete who earned a place on the All-WPIAL second team as a tight end and received a scholarship to Muskingum University. However, in a selfless act of love, he chose to forgo his education to care for his mother and younger brother, Ivan, following his father’s passing. He worked for 17 years as a bartender at the Welcome Café in Midland, but he was best known as a master butcher and the proud owner of Andy’s Market, a cornerstone of the Midland community. Known for his generosity, Andy never let anyone leave his store hungry. To his many great-nieces and nephews, he was affectionately known as “Uncle Candy.” He was a lifelong sports enthusiast who was a mentor and role model to many, especially his brother, Ivan, his son and best friend, Andrew, and his grandsons John and Michael, whom he “coached” both in sports and in life. His tireless work ethic and sense of humor inspired all who knew him, especially his first employees and nieces, Carolyn and Andrea. In retirement, he continued to serve his community as a board member for the Midland Water Authority and as a volunteer usher at Lincoln Park Performing Arts Center. He also remained an active member of St. Augustine Parish and St. Blaise Church in Midland. He never met a stranger. He was known for his warm smile, his trademark “Yeah, man!” greeting, and his unwavering kindness. His presence brought light and laughter to every room, and he will be deeply missed by all who had the good fortune to know him.
Friends will be received on Thursday, November 13th from 2 p.m. until 8 p.m. in the Schwerha-Noll Funeral Home, 629 Midland Avenue, Midland, who was in charge of his arrangements. A Mass of Christian Burial will be celebrated on Friday, November 14th at 10:30 a.m. at St. Blaise Church, 772 Ohio Ave, Midland. Burial will follow at Beaver Cemetery, Buffalo Street, Beaver. Online condolences may be shared at nollfuneral.com.
In lieu of flowers, memorial donations in Andy’s name may be made to St. Augustine Parish, St. Blaise Church, 772 Ohio Ave, Midland, PA 15059
“You set an example and a standard so high I’ll never be able to reach it, but for loving you, I’ll never get tired of trying. I have had many coaches and mentors in my life, but none was as great as you. You are my hero.” — Andrew Toncic, Jr.